章节

中国社会工作循证实践与研究综述

摘要

循证社会工作是推动社会工作学科科学化和本土化探索的重要抓手,但该范式在我国的应用情况还不清晰,需要对其进行归纳以推动循证社会工作范式的进一步应用。遵循PRISMA-ScR指南,运用范围综述方法,在中国知识资源总库和Web of Science两个数据库中对51本社会工作中英文期刊进行检索,依据“证据分级框架”进行数据归类,最终纳入发表在41本中英文社会工作期刊上的1028篇文献。研究发现,社会工作期刊中循证研究证据总量持续上升,部分高校带头发展;高证据分级研究增速加快、低证据分级研究基础扎实。研究结果表明,我国循证社会工作发展重点已从“知识生产”转向“知识转化”阶段,建议政策和教育先行,优化高校和社会组织的合作机制,推动循证社会工作的进一步发展。

作者

孙希希 ,华东理工大学社会与公共管理学院社会工作(学)博士研究生。
段文杰 ,华东理工大学社会与公共管理学院教授、博士生导师。
王子川 ,华东理工大学社会与公共管理学院社会工作专业硕士研究生。

参考文献 查看全部 ↓
  • 安秋玲、李强、鲁琳(2020):“上海低收入家庭中亲子冲突的干预:一项随机实验研究”,《社会工作与管理》第20卷第4期,第5~11、36页。
  • 陈金凤、朱眉华(2021)“流动儿童学业拖延行为的小组干预研究”,《社会工作与管理》第21卷第4期,第25~32、62页。
  • 段文杰、卜禾(2018):“基于优势的干预实验及其机制研究——以改善大学新生心理健康的干预为例”,《社会工作》第6期,第42~51、110页。
  • 郭伟和(2019):“专业实践中实证知识和实践逻辑的辩证关系——以循证矫正处境化实践为例”,《社会学研究》第34卷第5期,第116~137、244页。
  • 何雪松(2004):“证据为本的实践的兴起及其对中国社会工作发展的启示”,《华东理工大学学报》(社会科学版)第1期,第13~18页。
  • 李希希、韩晓燕、赵鑫、王海萍、朱丽君(2014):“‘青少年正面成长计划’在中国大陆的客观成效性探究”,《儿童青少年与家庭社会工作评论》第2期,第185~201、317页。
  • 李筱、段文杰(2021):“循证社会工作的科学价值与学科价值——兼论开展循证社会工作的若干原则与方法”,《社会工作》第3期,第2~9、106页。
  • 李筱、何雪松(2021):“新文科建设、循证实践教育与社会工作的专业化发展”,《社会工作》第1期,第20~30、105~106页。
  • 刘畅、刘仕清、袁易卿、孙小悦、段文杰、何雪松(2020):“中国社会工作者的专业化——基于CSWLS 2019的数据分析”,载王思斌主编《中国社会工作研究》(第十九辑),第22~55、216~217页。
  • 刘玲、彭华民(2019):“逻各斯的失衡与道的平衡——循证社会工作的西学话语和东渐重构”,《社会科学》第10期,第76~87页。
  • 陆飞杰(2011):“上海社会工作者的离职原因探析——基于50位社工的访谈”,《社会工作》(学术版)第11期,第82~84、60页。
  • 彭瑾、李娜、郭申阳(2022):“社会工作研究中的定量方法及其应用”,《西安交通大学学报》(社会科学版)第42卷第1期,第46~57页。
  • 亓迪、沈佳飞(2020):“近十年国内外儿童发展研究综述——基于CiteSpace的可视化分析”,《社会工作与管理》第20卷第6期,第39~49、59页。
  • 孙鸿平、刘江(2017):“专业社会工作者留职影响因素研究:基于一项定性比较分析法(QCA)”,《社会工作》第4期,第77~85、111页。
  • 谭磊(2021):“循证社会工作:我国本土语境下理念与实务的融合”,《理论月刊》第2期,第109~115页。
  • 童峰、杨文登(2019):“循证社会工作:‘医养结合’的新力量”,《人民论坛》第25期,第48~49页。
  • 童敏、周晓彤(2022):“超越心理学与社会学:社会工作的在地性审视及其理论重构”,《厦门大学学报》(哲学社会科学版)第51卷第6期,第10~17页。
  • 王君健(2019):“循证社会工作建构的可能、挑战及趋向”,《社会科学家》第12期,第20~27页。
  • 王青平、范炜烽(2017):“伦理方法抑或技术路径:西部地区扶贫治理的循证实践”,《西藏大学学报》(社会科学版)第32卷第2期,第184~190页。
  • 王硕、杨静、高万红(2020):“绘本阅读提升农村幼儿情绪社会性能力的干预研究——以云南省楚雄州Y镇幼儿为例”,《社会工作与管理》第20卷第4期,第12~19页。
  • 王思斌(2014):“社会治理结构的进化与社会工作的服务型治理”,《北京大学学报》(哲学社会科学版)第51卷第6期,第30~37页。
  • 熊贵彬(2020):“社区矫正三大管理模式及社会工作介入效果分析——基于循证矫正视角”,《浙江工商大学学报》第2期,第114~125页。
  • 杨克虎(2018):“循证社会科学的产生、发展与未来”,《图书与情报》第3期,第1~10页。
  • 杨梨、王曦影(2021):“国外残障学生欺凌干预研究综述与展望”,《社会工作与管理》第21卷第3期,第23~29页。
  • 杨阳、卢洁妤、魏志鹏、杨克虎(2023):“效度视角下的循证社会实践探析——基于社会工作、管理与法学三领域的比较研究”,《图书馆建设》第1期,第63~75页。
  • 叶托、余莉、陈丽丽(2022):“我国社会工作政策的变迁历程和演化逻辑——基于1987—2020年118份国家级政策文本的量化分析”,《长白学刊》第6期,第119~130页。
  • 易艳阳(2019):“残障社会工作循证实践模式本土化探究”,《社会工作》第5期,第88~95、111页。
  • 余冰、熊若杉(2017):“专业认同与行业认知——一项对中国大陆社会工作学生专业实习成效的质性研究”,《社会工作》第2期,第48~56、71、110~111页。
  • 张昱、彭少峰(2015):“走向适度循证的中国社会工作——社会工作本土实践探索及启示”,《福建论坛》(人文社会科学版)第5期,第160~166页。
  • 赵迪、张志鹏、张伟(2022):“因为专业所以认同——南京市社会工作者主观地位认同的质性研究”,《社会工作与管理》第22卷第3期,第23~34页。
  • 赵芳、朱宁(2019):“近三十年儿童保护研究进展与趋势——基于CiteSpace和HistCite的图谱量化分析”,《社会工作》第4期,第95~107、12页。
  • 郑广怀、朱苗(2021):“生态因素如何影响循证实践在社会工作专业化进程中的作用”,《学海》第3期,第77~85页。
  • 郑玉、关远、向德平(2021):“疫情防控常态化下流动儿童抗逆力提升的小组干预:一项随机对照试验”,《社会工作》第3期,第40~52、108页。
  • 周晓春、韩旭冬、张肖蒙、尹姝亚、聂睿(2021):“留守儿童抗逆力提升的历奇干预:基于混合方法试验研究的项目可行性探讨”,《社会工作与管理》第21卷第4期,第16~24页。
  • Aarons,G.A.(2004). “Mental Health Provider Attitudes Toward Adoption of Evidence-based Practice:the Evidence-Based Practice Attitude Scale.” Mental Health Service Research 6(2):19.
  • An,Q. & Li,Z.(2021). “An Intervention Study in Urban Low-Income Families:Promoting Family Functioning to Children.” Asia Pacific Journal of Social Work and Development 31(3):176-188.
  • Arksey,H. & O’malley,L.(2005). “Scoping Studies:Towards a Methodological Framework.” International Journal of Social Research Methodology 8(1):19-32.
  • Audin,J.M.-C.M.B.K.(2009). “Practice Research Networks for Effective PsychologicalTherapies.” Journal of Mental Health 10(3):241-251.
  • Bai,Z.G.,et al.(2022). “Evidence Based Social Science in China Paper 2:The History and Development of Evidence Based Social Work in China.” Journal of Clinical Epidemiology 141:151-156.
  • Bellamy,J.L.,Bledsoe,S.E. & Traube,D.E.(2006). “The Current State of Evidence-based Practice in Social Work:A Review of the Literature and Qualitative Analysis of Expert Interviews.” Journal of Evidence-Based Social Work 3(1):23-48.
  • Bender,K.,Altschul,I.,Yoder,J.,et al.(2014). “Training Social Work Graduate Students in the Evidence-based Practice Process.” Research on Social Work Practice 24(3):339-348.
  • Bu,H. & Duan,W.(2020). “Strength-Based Flourishing Intervention to Promote Resilience in Individuals With Physical Disabilities in Disadvantaged Communities:A Randomized Controlled Trial.” Research on Social Work Practice 31(1):53-64.
  • Burns,P.B.,Rohrich,R.J. & Chung,K.C.(2011). “The Levels of Evidence and Their Role in Evidence-based Medicine.” Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery 128(1):305-310.
  • Burt,R.S.(2004). “Structural Holes and Good Ideas.” American Journal of Sociology 110(2):349-399.
  • Campbell,B.(2010). “Applying Knowledge to Generate Action:A Community-based Knowledge Translation Framework.” Journal of Continuing Education in the Health Professions 30(1):65-71.
  • Chen,C.(2017). “Science Mapping:A Systematic Review of the Literature.” Journal of Data and Information Science 2(2):1-40.
  • Chen,Q.,Zhu,Y. & Chui,W.H.(2021). “A Meta-analysis on Effects of Parenting Programs on Bullying Prevention.” Trauma,Violence,Abuse 22(5):1209-1220.
  • Chen,Y. & Zhuang,J.(2020). “Roles of Medical Social Workers in Interprofessional Teams:A Case Study of a Shanghai COVID-19 Quarantine Centre for Medical Observation.” Asia Pacific Journal of Social Work and Development 31(1-2):123-131.
  • Cheng,M.,Smith,D.S.,Ren,X.,et al.(2023). “How New Ideas Diffuse in Science.” American Sociological Review 88(33):522-561.
  • Chiang,I.-C.A.,Jhangiani,R.S. & Price,P.C.(2015). Research Methods of Psychology. Victoria:BCcampus.
  • Colquhoun,H.L.,Levac,D.,O’brien,K.K.,et al.(2014). “Scoping Reviews:Time for Clarity in Definition,Methods,and Reporting.” Journal of Clinical Epidemiology 67(12):1291-4.
  • Cui,N. & Liu,J.(2020). “Physical Abuse,Emotional Abuse,and Neglect and Childhood Behavior Problems:A Meta-analysis of Studies in Mainland China.” Trauma,Violence,& Abuse 21(1):206-224.
  • Drisko,J.W. & Grady,M.D.(2015). “Evidence-based Practice in Social Work:A Contemporary Perspective.” Clinical Social Work Journal 43(3):274-282.
  • Duan,W. & Bu,H.(2019). “Randomized Trial Investigating of a Single-Session Character-Strength-Based Cognitive Intervention on Freshman’s Adaptability.” Research on Social Work Practice 29(1):82-92.
  • Duan,W.,Kong,Y.,Bu,H.,et al.(2022). The Online Strength-informed Acceptance and Commitment Therapy Among COVID-19-affected Adolescents.” Research on Social Work Practice 32(4):465-474.
  • Ekeland,T.-J.,Bergem,R. & Myklebust,V.(2018). “Evidence-based Practice in Social Work:Perceptions and Attitudes Among Norwegian Social Workers.” European Journal of Social Work 22(4):611-622.
  • Emparanza,J.I.,Cabello,J.B. & Burls,A.J.(2015). “Does Evidence-based Practice Improve Patient Outcomes?An Analysis of a Natural Experiment in a Spanish Hospital.” Journal of Evaluation in Clinical Practice 21(6):1059-1065.
  • Fang,X.,Fry,D.A.,Brown,D.S.,et al.(2015). “The Burden of Child Maltreatment in the East Asia and Pacific Region.” Child Abuse & Neglect 42:146-162.
  • Finne,J.(2020). “Evidence-based Practice in Social Work:Who are the Critics?” Journal of Social Work 21(6):1433-1449.
  • Gambrill,E.(2001). “Social Work:An Authority-based Profession.” Research on Social Work Practice 11(3):166-175.
  • Gao,S.,Assink,M.,Liu,T.,et al.(2021). “Associations Between Rejection Sensitivity,Aggression,and Victimization:A meta-analytic Review.” Trauma,Violence,& Abuse 22(1):125-135.
  • Gao,X.,Liu,C.H.,Guo,X.L.,et al.(2020). “Relationship Between Parental Psychological Control and Children’s Academic Achievement in China:The Role of Children’s Failure Mindsets.” Children and Youth Services Review 119:10.
  • Gibbs,L. & Gambrill,E.(2002). “Evidence-based practice:Counterarguments to objections.” Research on Social Work Practice 12(3):452-476.
  • Gilgun,J.F.(2005). “The Four Cornerstones of Evidence-based Practice in Social Work.” Research on Social Work Practice 15(1):52-61.
  • Gleeson,H.,Pezzella,A. & Rahman,N.(2021). “Learning to Become Evidence based Social Workers:Student Views on Research Education and Implementation in Practice.” Social Work Education:1-17.
  • Gray,M.,Joy,E.,Plath,D.,et al.(2015). “What Supports and Impedes Evidence-based Practice Implementation?A Survey of Australian Social Workers.” British Journal of Social Work 45(2):667-684.
  • Guan,S. & Deng,G.(2019). “Whole-community Intervention for Left-behind Children in Rural China.” Children and Youth Services Review 101:1-11.
  • Hartman,E.(2017). “The Queer Utility of Narrative Case Studies for Clinical Social Work Research and Practice.” Clinical Social Work Journal 45(3):227-237.
  • Hodge,D.R. & Turner,P.R.(2022). “Who are the Top 100 Contributors to Social Work Journal Scholarship?A Global Study on Career Impact in the Profession.” Research on Social Work Practice 33(3):338-349.
  • Hou,S.,Wang,Y.,Cai,P.,et al.(2021). “What Parents Bring to Preschool Children?Parental Instructive Speech and Gestures,Children’s Learning and Cultural Differences.” Children and Youth Services Review 127:106078.
  • Jin,Y.C.,Li,J.Y.,An,J.X.,et al.(2019). “The Differential Victimization Associated with Depression and Anxiety in Cross-Cultural Perspective:A Meta-analysis.” Trauma,Violence,& Abuse 20(4):560-573.
  • Kagan,M.(2022). “Social Workers’ Attitudes Towards Evidence-based Practice:A Multidimensional Perspective.” The British Journal of Social Work 52(8):4497-4517.
  • Ku,H.B. & Ho,D.K.L.(2020). “The Predicament of Social Work Development and the Emergence of Social Work Action/Practice Research in China.” Action Research 18(1):7-18.
  • Lei,H.,Chiu,M.M.,Cui,Y.,et al.(2018). “Parenting Style and Aggression:A Meta-analysis of Mainland Chinese Children and Youth.” Children and Youth Services Review 94:446-455.
  • Lei,H.,Chiu,M.M.,Li,F.,et al.(2020). “Computational Thinking and Academic Achievement:A Meta-Analysis Among Students.” Children and Youth Services Review 118.
  • Lei,H.,Chiu,M.M.,Quan,J.,et al.(2020). “Effect of Self-control on Aggression Among Students in China:A meta-analysis.” Children and Youth Services Review 116.
  • Lei,H.,Xiong,Y.,Chiu,M.M.,et al.(2021). “The Relationship Between ICT Literacy and Academic Achievement Among Students:A Meta-analysis.” Children and Youth Services Review 127.
  • Levine,K.A. & Kai,Z.(2010). “The Changing Context of China:Emerging Issues for School Social Work Practice.” International Social Work 53(3):339-352.
  • Li,H. & Wang,S.(2013). “The Role of Cognitive Distortion in Online Game Addiction Among Chinese Adolescents.” Children and Youth Services Review 35(9):1468-1475.
  • Lietz,C.A. & Zayas,L.E.(2010). “Evaluating Qualitative Research for Social Work Practitioners.” Advances in Social Work 11(2):188-202.
  • Lin,L.,Jiang,A.,Zheng,Y.,et al.(2021). “New Media Platform’s Understanding of Chinese Social Workers’ Anti-epidemic Actions:An Analysis of Network Public Opinion Based on COVID-19.” Social Work in Public Health 36(7-8):770-785.
  • Luo,Y.,Zhang,A. & Qi,A.(2023). “A Parent Education Program for Single Fathers’ Parent-Child Relationship in Rural China:A Pretest-Posttest-Follow-Up Study.” Research on Social Work Practice 33(4):413-422.
  • Magill,M.(2016). “The Future of Evidence in Evidence-Based Practice.” Journal of Social Work 6(2):101-115.
  • Nevo,I. & Slonim-Nevo,V.(2011). “The Myth of Evidence-Based Practice:Towards evidence-informed practice.” British Journal of Social Work 41(6):1176-1197.
  • Pendell,K. & Kimball,E.(2021). “Dissemination of Applied Research to the Field:Attitudes and Practices of Faculty Authors in Social Work.” Insights:The UKSG Journal 34.
  • Regehr,C.,Stern,S. & Shlonsky,A.(2016). “Operationalizing Evidence-based Practice:The Development of an Institute for Evidence-Based Social Work.” Research on Social Work Practice 17(3):408-416.
  • Rosen,A.(2003). “Evidence-based Social Work Practice:Challenges and Promise.” Social Work Research 27(4):197-208.
  • Rubin,A. & Bellamy,J.L.(2012). Practitioner’s Guide to Using Research for Evidence-based Practice. Hoboken:John Wiley & Sons.
  • Rubin,A.(2008). Practitioner’s Guide to Using Research for Evidence-Based Practice. Hoboken:John Wiley & Sons,Inc.
  • Rubin,A.(2014). “Efforts to Bridge the Gap Between Research and Practice in Social Work.” Research on Social Work Practice 25(4):408-414.
  • Shaya,F.T. & Gu,A.(2006). “Deriving Effectiveness Information for Decision-making.” Expert Review of Pharmacoeconomics & Outcomes Research 6(1):5-7.
  • Shneider,A.M.(2009). “Four Stages of a Scientific Discipline:Four Types of Scientist.” Trends in Biochemical Science 34(5):217-223.
  • Siddaway,A.P.,Wood,A.M. & Hedges,L.V.(2019). “How to Do a Systematic Review:A Best Practice Guide for Conducting and Reporting Narrative Reviews,Meta-analyses,and Meta-syntheses.” Annual Review of Psychology 70:747-770.
  • Stanhope,V.,Tuchman,E. & Sinclair,W.(2010). “The Implementation of Mental Health Evidence Based Practices From the Educator,Clinician and Researcher Perspective.” Clinical Social Work Journal 39(4):369-378.
  • Tang,Y.(2020). “Challenges and Rewards of Social Work Pioneers in the‘Making’Process:A Qualitative Study.” Journal of Social Service Research 46(6):813-824.
  • Thyer,B.A. & Myers,L.L.(2011). “The Quest for Evidence-Based Practice:A View From the United States.” Journal of Social Work 11(1):8-25.
  • Thyer,B.A. & Pignotti,M.(2011). “Evidence-based Practices Do not Exist.” Clinical Social Work Journal 39(4):328-333.
  • Tricco,A.C.,Lillie,E.,Zarin,W.,et al.(2018). “PRISMA Extension for Scoping Reviews(PRISMA-ScR):Checklist and Explanation.” Annals of Internal Medicine 169(7):467-473.
  • Wang,L. & Liu,C.(2022). “What Did Chinese Social Workers Do at the Worst Moment?A Research Based on Social Workers’ Participation in the Fight Against COVID-19 at Guangzhou.” Social Work in Public Health:1-12.
  • Wang,M. & Liu,K.(2023). “Self-Recognition,Self-Efficacy,and Confidence Intervention of Kunjing Children Without Sufficient Parental Care.” Research on Social Work Practice 33(8):849-860.
  • Wang,Y.X.,Chen,S.Q. & Wang,Y.Q.(2022). “Toward Four Basic Systems of Trauma-informed Practice for COVID-19-affected Communities in China:Framework Analysis from Social Workers’ Perspectives.” Journal of Social Service Research 48(3):329-344.
  • Wen,Y.J.,Hou,W.P.,Zheng,W.,et al.(2021). “The Neglect of Left-behind Children in China:A meta-analysis.” Trauma,Violence,& Abuse 22(5):1326-1338.
  • Wu,F.,Fraser,M.W.,Guo,S.,et al.(2014). “Strengthening the Social Information-Processing Skills of Children:A Controlled Test of the Let’s Be Friends Program in China.” Research on Social Work Practice 26(5):525-538.
  • Wu,J.,Chen,K.,Ma,Y.,et al.(2020). “Early Intervention for Children with Intellectual and Developmental Disability Using Drama Therapy Techniques.” Children and Youth Services Review 109:104689.
  • Wu,L.,Huang,Y.,Chen,Q.,et al.(2021). “Social Work Students’ Experiences of Ethical Difficulties in Field Placements:A Qualitative Study in China.” The British Journal of Social Work 51(2):505-523.
  • Wu,Y.J. & Chen,A.N.(2022). “Unfolding Turnover:The Turnover Decision-making Process of Social Workers in China.” Journal of Social Service Research 48(2):187-199.
  • Zeng,S.C.,Cheung,M.,Leung,P.,et al.(2016). “Voices From Social Work Graduates in China:Reasons for Not Choosing Social Work as a Career.” Social Work 61(1):69-78.
  • Zhang,H.,Ji,M.,Wang,Y.,Xu,S.,& Shi,R.(2023). “Early Childhood Neglect Among 3-to 6-year-old Children in China:A Meta-analysis.” Trauma,Violence,& Abuse 24(1):3-14.
  • Zhang,H.,Li,J.,Sun,B.,et al.(2021). “Effects of Childhood Maltreatment on Self-compassion:A systematic review and Meta-analysis.” Trauma,Violence,& Abuse:1-13.
  • Zhang,H.,Shi,R.,Li,Y.,et al.(2021). “Effectiveness of School-based Child Sexual Abuse Prevention Programs in China:A Meta-analysis.” Research on Social Work Practice 31(7):693-705.
  • Zhang,J.,Yan,L.,Qiu,H.,et al.(2018). “Social Adaptation of Chinese Left-behind Children:Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis.” Children and Youth Services Review 95:308-315.
  • Zhang,Q.,Cao,Y.,Tian,J.,et al.(2020). “Effects of Prosocial Cartoon Models on Aggressive Cognitions and Aggressive Behaviors.” Children and Youth Services Review 118:105498.
  • Zhang,Y.Y.(2022). “Structural Barriers and Narratives of Chinese Social Workers’ Coping Strategies.” Human Service Organizations Management Leadership & Governance:22.
  • Zhao,Y.,Du,M.,Gao,X.,et al.(2016). “Altered Brain Network Topology in Left-behind Children:A Resting-State Functional Magnetic Resonance Imaging Study.” Child Abuse & Neglect 62:89-99.
  • Zhuang,X.,Lau,Y.Y.,Huang,Y.-T.,et al.(2022). “Efficacy of Low-Intensity Cognitive Behavior Intervention for Chinese Delinquent Youth.” Research on Social Work Practice 32(2):155-167.

中国社会工作循证实践与研究综述

可试读20%内容 PDF阅读 阅读器阅览

试读已结束,剩余80%未读

¥7.23 查看全文 >

VIP免费

章节目录

  • 一 引言
  • 二 研究方法
    1. (一)文献分类依据:证据分级框架
    2. (二)文献检索策略
    3. (三)文献纳入和排除标准
    4. (四)文献筛选过程
  • 三 结果与分析
    1. (一)纳入文献总体呈上升趋势,部分高校带头发展
    2. (二)纳入文献整体证据分级水平有待提高
      1. 1.系统综述研究数量突增
      2. 2.实验研究数量较少
      3. 3.相关研究占比最高
      4. 4.叙事案例研究增速平稳
  • 四 结论与讨论
    1. (一)循证社会工作迅猛发展,高校发挥带头作用
    2. (二)循证社会工作发展已转向“知识转化”阶段
    3. (三)研究的局限性
  • 五 对策与建议
    1. (一)政策先行推动循证社会工作进一步发展
    2. (二)全面优化高校与社会组织合作机制
    3. (三)教育促进循证社会工作研究升级

章节图片/图表

查看更多>>>