章节

从冲突到善治:社会转型时期的秩序反思与道德重建

摘要

每逢社会重大变革,善恶、是非问题总是特别引人注目。道德法则究竟是为冲突筑高地,还是为善治求良方,是值得审问、慎思的理论问题,更是需要明辨、笃行的实践课题。如今,恰逢人类百年未有之大变局,社会变迁与技术变革引发了一系列秩序反思与道德重建的大讨论。本文首先从冲突视角回顾了道德心理学的最新进展,然后从道德与秩序反思、道德与个人成长、道德与文化建设、道德与共同体建设、道德心理思想史等方面,简要介绍了国内外学者在化解规范冲突、推动社会善治上的最新努力和研究发现。

作者

吴胜涛 ,博士,厦门大学社会与人类学院副教授、博士生导师。本科毕业于北京师范大学哲学系,中国科学院心理研究所博士。研究兴趣包括社会文化变迁与心理适应,正义与社会规范,大数据分析等。国际跨文化心理学会、国际正义研究学会、亚洲社会心理学会会员,中国心理学会心理学与社会治理专业委员会、文化心理学专业委员会理事,中国社会学会社会心理学专业委员会理事,中国社会心理学会网络与大数据专业委员会理事。在Journal of Personality、International Journal of Psychology、Social Justice Research、《科学通报》、《中国科学院院刊》等期刊上发表学术论文40余篇。《心理学学科发展报告》(2016-2017)道德心理学部分执笔人。 电子信箱:michaelstwu@xmu.edu.cn或wust2011@163.com。
胡传鹏 ,南京师范大学心理学院教授。
刘冠民 ,天津大学应用心理研究所副研究员。

参考文献 查看全部 ↓
  • 胡传鹏、邓晓红、周治金、邓小刚,2011,《神经法学:年轻的认知神经科学与古老的法学联姻》,《科学通报》第36期。
  • 吴胜涛、王平丽、陈咏媛,2020,《亲社会正义感的阶层差异:个体主义的调节作用》,《中国社会心理学评论(第17辑)》,社会科学文献出版社。
  • 杨金花、金盛华、曾美英、吴南、徐华,2017,《贫富群体心理融合中的“富人道德极化”现象》,《心理学进展》第11期。
  • 杨沈龙、郭永玉、胡小勇、舒首立、李静,2016,《低阶层者的系统合理化水平更高吗?——基于社会认知视角的考察》,《心理学报》第11期。
  • 张语嫣、许丽颖、喻丰、丁晓军、邬家骅、赵靓,2022,《算法拒绝的三维动机理论》,《心理科学进展》第5期。
  • Algoe,S.B.,Haidt,J. & Gable,S.L.(2008). Beyond Reciprocity:Gratitude and Relationships in Everyday Life. Emotion,8(3),425.
  • Awad,E.,Dsouza,S.,Kim,R.,Schulz,J.,Henrich,J.,Shariff,A.,Bonnefon,J. & Rahwan,I.(2018). The Moral Machine Experiment. Nature,563(7729),59-64.
  • Barrett,H.C.,Bolyanatz,A.,Crittenden,A.N.,Fessler,D.M.,Fitzpatrick,S.,Gurven,M.,…& Laurence,S.(2016). Small-scale Societies Exhibit Fundamental Variation in the Role of Intentions in Moral Judgment. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences,113(17),4688-4693.
  • Bernhard,H.,Fischbacher,U.,& Fehr,E.(2006). Parochial altruism in humans. Nature,442,912-915.
  • Bianchi,E.C.(2016). American Individualism Rises and Falls with the Economy:Cross-temporal Evidence that Individualism Declines When the Economy Falters. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology,111(4),567.
  • Boaz,D.(2016). Gallup Finds more Libertarians in the Electorate,Cato Institute. Retrieved from https://policycommons.net/artifacts/1308535/gallup-finds-more-libertarians-in-the-electorate/1911826/on 01 May 2022.CID:20.500.12592/vmtn3q.
  • Boaz,D. & Kirby,D.(2006). The Libertarian Vote. Cato Institute Policy Analysis Series,(580),1-26.
  • Boaz,D.(2015). Libertarianism is on the Vergeof a Political Breakout,Cato Institute. Retrieved from https://time.com/3695448/rand-paul-libertarianism-political-breakout/.
  • Brandt,M.J.(2013). Do the Disadvantaged Legitimize the Social System?A Large-scale Test of the Status-legitimacy Hypothesis. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology,104(5),765.
  • Cai,H.,Kwan,V.S. & Sedikides,C.(2012). A Sociocultural Approach to Narcissism:The Case of Modern China. European Journal of Personality,26(5),529-535.
  • Cameron,C.D.,Lindquist,K.A. & Gray,K.(2015). A Constructionist Review of Morality and Emotions:No Evidence for Specific Links between Moral Content and Discrete Emotions. Personality and Social Psychology Review,19,371-394.
  • Doris,J.M. & Stich,S.(2014). Moral Psychology:Empirical Approaches. The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy(Fall 2014 Edition),Edward NZ(ed.),URL:https://plato.stanford.edu/archives/fall2014/entries/moral-psych-emp/.
  • Fehr,E.,Glätzle-Rützler,D. & Sutter,M.(2013). The Development of Egalitarianism,Altruism,Spite and Parochialism in Childhood and Adolescence. European Economic Review,64,369-383.
  • Fessler,D.M.,Barrett,H.C.,Kanovsky,M.,Stich,S.,Holbrook,C.,Henrich,J.,…& Laurence,S.(2015). Moral Parochialism and Contextual Contingency across Seven Societies. Proceedings of the Royal Society B:Biological Sciences,282(1813),20150907.
  • Fukuyama,F.(1999). The great disruption:Human Nature and the Reconstruction of Social Order. New York:The Free Press.
  • Garrett,K.N. & Bankert,A.(2020). The Moral Roots of Partisan Division:How Moral Conviction Heightens Affective Polarization. British Journal of Political Science,50(2),621-640.
  • Graham,J.,Haidt,J. & Nosek,B.A.(2009). Liberals and Conservatives Rely on Different Sets of Moral Foundations. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology,96(5),1029.
  • Graham,J.,Nosek,B.A. & Haidt,J.(2012). The Moral Stereotypes of Liberals and Conservatives:Exaggeration of Differences across the Political Spectrum. PloS one,7(12),5682-5700.
  • Greene,J.D.,Cushman,F.A.,Stewart,L.E.,Lowenberg,K.,Nystrom,L.E. & Cohen,J.D.(2009). Pushing Moral Buttons:The Interaction between Personal Force and Intention in Moral Judgment. Cognition,111(3),364-371.
  • Greenfield,P.M.(2009). Linking Social Change and Developmental Change:ShiftingPathways of Human Development. Developmental Psychology,45(2),401.
  • Greenfield,P.M.(2013). The changing psychology of from 1800 through 2000. Psychological Science,24(9),1722-1731.
  • Haidt,J. & Graham,J.(2007). When Morality OpposesJustice:Conservatives have Moral Intuitions that Liberals May not Recognize. Social Justice Research,20(1),98-116.
  • Haidt,J.(2012). The Righteous Mind Why Good People Are Divided by Politics and Religion. New York:Vintage Books.
  • Halevy,N.,Kreps,T.A.,Weisel,O. & Goldenberg,A.(2015). Morality in Intergroup Conflict. Current Opinion in Psychology,6,10-14.
  • Halevy,N.,Weisel,O. & Bornstein,G.(2012). “In-group love” and “out-group hate” in Repeated Interaction between Groups. Journal of Behavioral Decision Making,25(2),188-195.
  • Huang,L.,Sun.Y. & Luo,S.(2022). The Impact of Culture on the Speed of Pandemic Control:Based on the Background of COVID-19). Acta Psychologica Sinica,54(5),497-515.
  • Hussak,L.J. & Cimpian,A.(2015). An Early-emerging Explanatory Heuristic Promotes Support for the Status Quo. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology,109(5),739.
  • Iyer,R.,Koleva,S.,Graham,J.,Ditto,P. & Haidt,J.(2012). Understanding Libertarian Morality:The Psychological Dispositions of Self-identified Libertarians. PLOS One,7(8),e42366.
  • Jost,J.T.,Pelham,B.W.,Sheldon,O. & Ni Sullivan,B.(2003). Social Inequality and the Reduction of Ideological Dissonance on Behalf of the System:Evidence of Enhanced System Justification among the Disadvantaged. European Journal of Social Psychology,33(1),13-36.
  • Kraus,M.W.,Piff,P.K. & Keltner,D.(2009). Social Class,Sense of Control,and Social Explanation. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology,97(6),992.
  • Lincicome,S.(2022)This “Libertarian Moment” Could be more Lasting,Cato Institute. Retrieved from https://policycommons.ne/artifacts/2265863/this-libertarian-moment-could-be-more-lasting/3025527/on 03 May 2022.CID:20.500.12592/tng2mz.
  • Liu,G.,Zeng,G.,Wang,F.,Rotshtein,P.,Peng,K. & Sui,J.(2018). Praising Others Differently:Neuroanatomical Correlates to Individual Differences in Trait Gratitude and Elevation. Social Cognitive and Affective Neuroscience,13(12),1225-1234.
  • Lu,J.G.,Jin,P. & English,A.S.(2021). Collectivism predicts mask use during covid-19. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences,118(23),e2021793118.
  • Mullen,E. & Skitka,L.J.(2006). Exploring the Psychological Underpinnings of the Moral Mandate Effect:Motivated Reasoning,Group Differentiation,or Anger?Journal of Personality and Social Psychology,90(4),629.
  • Paxton,J.M,Ungar,L. & Greene,J.D.(2012). Reflection and Reasoning in Moral Judgment. Cognitive Science,36,163-177.
  • Piff,P.K.,Stancato,D.M.,Côté,S.,Mendoza-Denton,R. & Keltner,D.(2012). Higher Social Class Predicts Increased Unethical Behavior. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences,109(11),4086-4091.
  • Piff,P.K.(2014). Wealth and the Inflated Self:Class,Entitlement,and Narcissism. Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin,40(1),34-43.
  • Putnam,R.D.(2015). Our Kids the American Dream in Crisis. Simon & Schuster.
  • Rambaud,S.,Collange,J.,Tavani,J.L. & Zenasni,F.(2021). Positive Intergroup Interdependence,Prejudice,Outgroup Stereotype and Helping Behaviors:The Role of Group-based Gratitude. International Review of Social Psychology,34(1).
  • Skitka,L.J.,Bauman,C.W. & Sargis,E.G.(2005). Moral Conviction:Another Contributor to Attitude Strength or Something More?Journal of Personality and Social Psychology,88(6),895.
  • Skitka,L.J.,Morgan,G.S. & Wisneski,D.C.(2015). Political Orientation and Moral Conviction:A Conservative Advantage or an Equal Opportunity Motivator of Political Engagement. Social Psychology and Politics,57-74.
  • Van Bavel,J.J.,Rathje,S.,Harris,E.,Robertson,C. & Sternisko,A.(2021). How Social Media Shapes Polarization. Trends in Cognitive Sciences,25(11),913-916.
  • Varnum,M.E.,Blais,C.,Hampton,R.S. & Brewer,G.A.(2015). Social Class Affects Neural Empathic Responses. Culture and Brain,3(2),122-130.
  • Xu,Y. & Hamamura,T.(2014). Folk Beliefs of Cultural Changes in China. Frontiers in Psychology,5,e1066.
  • Zeng,R. & Greenfield,P.M.(2015). Cultural Evolution Over the Last 40 Years in China:Using the Google Ngram Viewer to Study Implications of Social and Political Change for Cultural Values. International Journal of Psychology,50(1),47-55.

从冲突到善治:社会转型时期的秩序反思与道德重建

可试读20%内容 PDF阅读 阅读器阅览

试读已结束,剩余80%未读

¥7.33 查看全文 >

VIP免费