章节

美国现代慈善的两个黄金时代与慈善资本主义的前景

摘要

美国现代慈善事业的两个黄金时代都是伴随着市场经济创业潮而产生的。19世纪下半叶兴起的创业潮催生了第一个黄金时代,20世纪末以来的互联网创业潮带来了第二个黄金时代。这两个黄金时代的底层逻辑都是慈善资本主义。在第一个黄金时代,慈善被用来证明资本主义的合法性,建立了独立的非营利组织制度,实现了慈善与商业的制度性隔离。然而,在第二个黄金时代,慈善与商业越走越近,二者之间的隔离渐渐被突破。近年来,慈善资本主义受到了越来越多的质疑。批评者认为,作为美国资本主义经济制度的衍生物,慈善并不能矫正这一制度的内在失灵。

作者

张远凤 ,中南财经政法大学公共管理学院教授、博士生导师,湖北省公益创新研究会秘书长。
苗志茹 ,中南财经政法大学公共管理学院研究生。

参考文献 查看全部 ↓
  • 〔美〕奥利维尔·聪茨(2016):《美国慈善史》,杨敏译,上海:上海财经大学出版社。
  • 程恩富、蒯正明(2018):《美国基金会“慈善”的内幕和实质》,《毛泽东邓小平理论研究》,第12期。
  • 高卫泉(2020):《慈善资本主义批判:从〈阿拉比〉中的“虚荣人”谈起》,《外国文学》,第4期。
  • 〔美〕莱斯特·萨拉蒙(2008):《公共服务中的伙伴——现代福利国家中政府与非营利组织的关系》,田凯译,北京:商务印书馆。
  • 〔美〕莱斯特·萨拉蒙(2017):《撬动公益——慈善和社会投资新前沿导论》,叶托、张远凤译,北京:社会科学文献出版社。
  • 〔美〕莱斯特·萨拉蒙(2007):《全球公民社会——非营利部门视界》,贾西津、魏玉等译,北京:社会科学文献出版社。
  • 〔美〕马修·比索普、迈克尔·格林(2011):《慈善资本主义:富人在如何拯救世界》,丁开杰等译,北京:社会科学文献出版社。
  • 徐永光(2017):《公益向右 商业向左》,北京:中信出版社。
  • 杨团(2007):《一场新的慈善革命:“慈善资本主义”与公益伙伴关系》,《学习与实践》,第3期。
  • 资中筠(2015):《财富的责任与资本主义演变:美国百年公益发展的启示》,上海:上海三联书店。
  • Arco-Castro,M.L.,Lopez-Pérez,M.V.,& Rodriguez-Gomez,S.(2020),“Do Stakeholders Modulate Philanthropic Strategy?Corporate Philanthropy as Stakeholders’ Engagement,” Sustainability 12(18),pp.1-18.
  • Bertrand,M.,Bombardini,M.,& Fisman,R.(2020),“Tax-Exempt Lobbying:Corporate Philanthropy as a Tool for Political Influence,” American Economic Review 110(7),pp.2065-2102.
  • Bielefeld,W.,& Cleveland,W.S.(2013),“Faith-Based Organizations as Service Providers and Their Relationship to Government,” Nonprofit and Voluntary Sector Quarterly 42(3),pp.468-494.
  • Bishop,M.(2013),“Philanthrocapitalism:Solving Public Problems through Private Means,” Social Research 80(2),pp.473-490.
  • Bishop,M.,& Green,M.(2015),“Philanthrocapitalism Rising,” Society 52(6),pp.541-548.
  • Brockner,J.,Senior,D.,& Welch,W.(2014),“Corporate Volunteerism,the Experience of Self-Integrity,and Organizational Commitment:Evidence from The Field,” Social Justice Research 27(1),pp.1-23.
  • Collings-Wells,S.(2020),“From Black Power to Broken Windows:Liberal Philanthropy and the Carceral State,” Journal of Urban History 48(4),pp.1-21.
  • Edwards,M.(2009),“Gates,Google and The Ending of Global Poverty:Philanthrocapitalism and International Development,” Brown Journal of World Affairs 15(2),pp.35-42.
  • Edwards,M.(2011),“Impact,Accountability and Philanthrocapitalism,” Society 48(5),pp.389-390.
  • Edwards,M.(2008),Just Another Emperor:The Myth and Realities of Philanthrocapitalism,New York:Demos.
  • Edwards,M.,& Liberman,V.(2010),“When Doing Good Is Bad,” Conference Board Review 47(2),pp.57-59.
  • Göçmen,I.(2013),“The Role of Faith-Based Organizations in Social Welfare Systems:A Comparison of France,Germany,Sweden,and the United Kingdom,” Nonprofit and Voluntary Sector Quarterly 42(3),pp.495-516.
  • Harvey,C.,Gordon,J.,& Maclean,M.(2021),“The Ethics of Entrepreneurial Philanthropy,” Journal of Business Ethics 171(1),pp.33-49.
  • Hall,P.D.(2005),“Historical Perspective on Nonprofit Organizations in the United States,” Herman,R.D. & Associates,eds.,The Jossey-Bass Handbook of Nonprofit Leadership and Management(2nd ed.),San Francisco:Jossey-Bass.
  • Holmes,G.(2012),“Biodiversity for Billionaires:Capitalism,Conservation and The Role of Philanthropy in Saving/Selling Nature,” Development and Change 43(1),pp.185-203.
  • Horvath,A.,& Powell,W.(2016),“Contributory or Disruptive:Do New Forms of Philanthropy Erode Democracy?,” Reich,R.,Cordelli,C.,& Bernholz,L.,eds.,Philanthropy in Democratic Societies,Chicago:University of Chicago Press.
  • Liberman,V.(2010),“When Doing Good Is Bad,” Conference Board Review 47(2),pp.57-59.
  • Manning,P.,Baker,N.,& Stokes,P.(2020),“The Ethical Challenge of Big Tech’s Disruptive Philanthropy,” International Studies of Management and Organization 50(3),pp.271-290.
  • Mccarthy,J.,& Castelli,J.(2010),“Religion-Sponsored Social Service Providers:The Not-So-Independent Sector,” Aspen Institute Nonprofit Sector Research Fund Unpublished.
  • Mitchell,K.,& Sparke,M.(2016),“The New Washington Consensus:Millennial Philanthropy and The Making of Global Market Subjects,” Antipode 48(3),pp.724-749.
  • Porter,M.E.,& Kramer,M.R.(2011),“Creating Shared Value,” Harvard Business Review 89(1-2),pp.62-77.
  • Sklair,J.,& Glucksberg,L.(2020),“Philanthrocapitalism as Wealth Management Strategy:Philanthropy,Inheritance and Succession Planning among The Global Elite,” The Sociological Review (2),pp.314-329.
  • Salamon,L.M.(2012),The State of Nonprofit America,Washington D.C.:Brookings Institution Press.
  • Salamon,L.M.,Sokolowski,S.W.,& Haddock,M.A.(2017),Explaining Civil Society Development:A Social Origins Approach,Baltimore:Johns Hopkins University Press.
  • Stritt,S.B.(2008),“Estimating the Value of the Faith-Based Organizations in the United States,” Nonprofit and Voluntary Sector Quarterly 37(4),pp.730-742.
  • Zou,P.(2021),“Too Little or Too Much?The Dynamic Adjustment of Corporate Philanthropy,” Applied Economics 53(2),pp.221-234.

美国现代慈善的两个黄金时代与慈善资本主义的前景

可试读20%内容 PDF阅读 阅读器阅览

试读已结束,剩余80%未读

¥5.17 查看全文 >

VIP免费